A controversial Facebook post by a top-ranking Guilford County Sherriff’s Department administrator has ignited a conversation about what does or does not constitute racism – and, in particular, whether the popular game of Eight-ball is racist and should not be played.
Sheriff’s Department Executive Administrative Assistant Catherine Netter posted on her Facebook page that the game of Eight-ball – which is won when the white ball knocks the black ball off the table – is a highly racist game, and she added, “I better NOT see a black person playing pool the traditional way.”
In the post, Netter stated that she was at a girlfriend’s home when she pointed out that an adjustment to the pool game was needed in order for it not to be racist.
“The eight-ball is the lead ball and the cue ball is the target,” Netter stated in the post. “The colors can be switched up but to play the traditional way is the most racist thing ever where the black (8) ball is targeted by the white ball (cue) and if any of his (black ball) other homies of color die before he does, then the game starts over because he hasn’t suffered enough.”
Netter also wrote that racism was further evident in the fact that all of the balls other than the white ball have numbers – which, she said, are “indicative of our criminal justice system.”
Sometimes people post things on Facebook as a joke or simply to “troll” others – an attempt to get strong reactions through an intentionally controversial posting – however, on Monday, July 8, Netter said her post was in no way shape or form a joke and that the game of Eight-ball is a patently racist game that shouldn’t be played by right-thinking people. She added that she would not tolerate racism in any form – be it in the hiring practices of the Sheriff’s Department or in the design of a billiard’s game.
Netter spoke very passionately about the matter.
“What’s going on with this game?” Netter said. “The person who designed it is the most racist human being ever. The cue ball is white; the eight-ball is black and the target is for the white ball to knock the eight-ball off the table.”
She said that, as a black woman who attempts to battle racism in all its forms on a daily basis, the game, as played, is intolerable.
“At what point do we not call out racism for what it is?” she asked. “I think it is a sad phenomenon that, in 2019, we’re still having to fight racism.”
Netter added that she was very fortunate that she had a father with good critical thinking skills who, when she was a child, explained the true nature of the game to her and helped her understand its racist essence. She said that she isn’t claiming that everyone who plays the game is a racist since people only know what they’re taught. She said she hoped to help more people realize the racist nature of the game.
Several people who contacted the Rhino Times regarding Netter’s posts were critical of Netter, saying that her post displays a type of unfounded racial anger and a biased way of thinking that does not benefit the Sheriff’s Department.
One critic of Netter said, “I wonder how she feels about bowling – I suspect she’s a fan.”
Does she have any historical evidence of the creators’ motivations? The game itself originated around 1900. Can she provide documentation from that time to prove that her claims have any factual basis? If not, then her father was just making things up as he went along.
You got it right Josh, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eight-ball
The history of billiards and pool goes back much further than the 1900s because it originated with the outdoor play of games like croquet in the 1300s. The misinformed Netter can look it up online like I’ve just done. I’m not helping her because I won’t be able to change her mind.
I have never heard Netter’s explanation of the game of pool as knocking the crap out of the eight-ball, and in fact, the idea is to knock your other colors into the pockets BEFORE knocking the eight-ball into the pocket as the LAST ball, so it seems you’d want to avoid it as much as possible. Looking at over 10 articles online about pool and billiards, the meaning of the colors of pool balls, and specifically of the black pool ball, only once very briefly was it mentioned that in the US there were African Americans who viewed it as representing them. Nowhere else was that stated, including one about playing pool in Africa. Generally, articles stated that the black pool ball represented good luck, being fortunate, being wealthy, being part of a gang, having a tendency to be late or really busy.
Netter should not be working in the Sheriff’s Department after the end of the week based on the firing last week of two people who posted some kind of inappropriate comments on the Julian FD Facebook page. Her comments may have been on her private page but her uninformed comment about the goals of the game of pool show that she doesn’t do research before speaking in public, she doesn’t have common sense, she has little education in Western Culture, she’s not capable of being objective in matters regarding racial issues and viewing things from a historical perspective, and that she seems to have ulterior motives in her decision making.
I’m tired of the ideas of racism in every little thing being beaten over our heads. Grow up, be mature and do your job. Fussing at people for playing an ancient game is not a huge issue when babies are being shot in the head in our neighborhoods.
Thanks to the previous comments trying to set the record straight on a simple game. I may have to rid my house of games such as dominoes – no telling what hidden message could be lurking in such a game! Must everything come down to racism?
I, for one, would like to hear more about the lawsuits that Ms. Netter has filed, which Randy has brought up. Please enlighten us, Scott. You have the only publication we can trust!
Deborah, thank you for stating the obvious! Wake up Guilford County!
This will likely just blow over, but consider the obverse
Mrs. Netter has a long history of abusing others and making false racism claims as evidenced by her lost lawsuits.
This absurd claim illustrates the victim mentality that permeates the black community and it is unfortunate because it holds many back.
Each sport (or hobby) uses some ball or piece that could be twisted into victimhood if you tried hard enough.
I feel sorry for Mrs. Netter for the legacy her father left her. He wasn’t a critical thinker. He was a perpetual victim that passed that on to his daughter…
This is absolutely asinine! Who thinks in terms of black and white when playing a game? Do we consider black clouds and white clouds to be racist? Come’on now, get real!
AMEN DIANE PARNELL!
And this, from an Official in the Sheriff’s Department? I get so sick and tired of hearing Racist this and Racist that! I’m ashamed to say that I live in a county where a person in her position exists.
Nowadays, racists are found right behind the pointing finger.
The Sheriff is aware of her claims of being a victim, she sued the Sheriff Office at one time. Ok you have to decide if the Sheriff agrees with her or not, if she stays he agrees but has to play politics and if he does not agree, she is fired. I almost forgot, did a deputy not make a Facebook post and get mocked, what is the difference in the two I wonder. One is mocked by many, the other is promoted by the sheriff to the top.
PLEASE send your story to Rush Limbaugh. America needs a great laugh about the “ADMIN. ASSISTANT”. I think She’s not a ranking member of the staff.
If this idiot keeps her job, the fire fighters in Julian (?) that were fired are owed an apology, their jobs reinstated and any back pay doubled.
Netter demanded the High Point Jail Chaplain being fired for believing in issuing a Bible along with Koran request. Danny Rogers agreed with her and dismissed the Chaplain. Let’s see if he dismisses Netter………..
I agree with these comments, but to make difference CALL the sheriffs dept. to complain, then call your county commissioner or city council member, then call the local news. While the sheriff is a elected position his employees are NOT. They are county employees and subject to standards of conduct both on and off the job.
Congratulations citizens of Guilford County. This is what you voted in to lead our sheriffs dept. Hope you are all proud !!!!
Update…. she was fired.
Bowling is racist